ARCHIVED August 2023. Please visit for current information.

Davis - Starenko House

Davis - Starenko House

155 South Main Street, Fairport NY 14450


The Italianate style home at 155 South Main Street in Fairport was designated in 2014 an historic landmark by the Fairport Historic Preservation Commission (FHPC). This home, named Davis – Starenko House for its' current owners, who have lived there for over 40 years, was built circa 1860 by William M. Newman. It is located on the southeast corner of South Main and Orchard Street. It is an Italianate style house with a hipped roof, cupola and one-story columned front porch. The home met three of the five criteria for designation: historic personages, example of an architectural style and a feature of the neighborhood.

Historic Personages

William M. Newman – Monroe Chemical Company

Instrumental in the growth and prosperity of Fairport, William Newman came to Fairport in 1856 and worked as a bookkeeper for Daniel B. DeLand at the Fairport Chemical Works. In the early 1860s, Newman bought 10 acres of land on South Main Street. He built the Italianate house on South Main for him and his second wife Susan.

In 1864, collaborating with Henry A. and Daniel B. DeLand, Joseph Parce, and H. Monteque Moseley they established the Mt. Pleasant Cemetery Company, acquiring six of the ten acres owned by Newman. It was created for the soldiers and sailors from Fairport who had died in the Civil War. Newman became secretary of the company, a position he held until his death in 1902.

NewmanW.M.PortraitPHS1902PRPartnering with Lewis Jones in 1869, he formed the Jones, Newman & Hollister lumber business. In 1874, Mr. Newman ventured into the baking powder business, purchasing the W.I. Ayers Company and renaming it Newman and Son. After a disastrous fire leveled the complex, Newman built a new factory and formed the Monroe County Chemical Company, one of the important industries in Fairport.

Mr. Newman is known to have built at least three other homes in Fairport: 112 West Ave, 137 North Main and 11 West Church Street and several business facilities. These homes, three of which are designated landmarks, and the Monroe Chemical building at 62 N. Main Street are still standing today.

Shown to left is a portrait of Mr. Newman taken about 1902. The photo is on file in the Museum.

William Newman held the office of Town Clerk, and served as president and board member of the Board of Education of the Fairport Union School. He became a deacon at the First Baptist Church and served as Sunday School Superintendent. William Newman was a loyal member of the Prohibition Party, and in 1894 was nominated for the office of County Judge on that ticket.

The Gazley's – Dr. Weare Medicine Company
Carrie and Ernest Gazley purchased the property in 1906. A well-known Fairport businessman, Ernest H. Gazley lived in the house until his death. Involved in the patent medicine business for twenty-five years, Mr. Gazley came to own the Dr. Weare Medicine Company, steadily growing the business. Upon his death in 1915, Ernest Gazley was one of the most popular and widely known salesmen in New York, Pennsylvania, Ohio, and the New England states.

The Steffen's – Hupp Drug Store & Builder
Charles and Rose Steffen purchased the house and property in 1919, while owning and operating Hupp Drug Company on South Main Street. Circa 1932 - 1933, Charles Steffen, a mason contractor, moved the back portion of the house at 155 South Main Street to the east, creating the first house on the south side of Orchard Street (#10). In addition to building a new home for themselves, at 157 South Main Street in 1930 and developing Steffen's Greenhouses on the property, Charles Steffen went on to build at least five more houses on Orchard Street.

Guy Fraser Harrison – Conductor
From 1940 to 1949, English-American conductor Guy Fraser Harrison owned the property. Harrison came to Rochester in 1920 to serve as organist at St. Paul 's Episcopal Church. When the Eastman School was founded, he was named instructor of organ and piano, later becoming conductor of the Eastman Theatre Orchestra. An important figure in the musical life of Rochester, Harrison also was conductor of the Rochester Civic Orchestra and associate conductor of the Rochester Philharmonic Orchestra until 1951.

Dale T. Davis – Owner for over 45 years
The current owner, Dale T. Davis, has been living in the house since 1967. Dale is a writer, educator, publisher, producer, scholar, dramaturge, and advocate for young people. She was one of the founding poets of New York State Poets In The Schools. In 1979, she co-founded The New York State Literary Center with poet, translator, and editor A. Poulin, Jr. where she continues to serve as Executive Director.

Dale Davis has edited and published over six hundred books and anthologies of the writings of young people with whom she worked in the NYS Literary Center programs. Davis is also the founder and administrator for New York State's Arts In Correctional Education Network.

Excellent Example of Italianate Style

S.Main155perD.Davis1880sPRThis property clearly exhibits the identifying features of the Italianate style, which dominated American house construction between 1850 and 1880. The two-story, square form with wide, overhanging eaves, shallow hipped roof and cupola, are hallmarks of the Italianate style.

It also has a three-ranked facade, tall, narrow windows with crowns, and a single-story front porch. This is the most common type of this style, making up one-third of all Italianate houses.

The windows on the house are tall, narrow, double hung windows, many with segmental arches and simple crowns. The front porch windows have four-pane glazing in the window sashes, with an unusually wide vertical muntin and a narrow horizontal muntin. The lower sash on first floor porch windows has single-pane glazing.

The cupola features triple and quadruple, narrow segmental arched windows with horizontal muntins.

The front of the house features a full-width porch with four fluted Doric columns on pedestals. Matching pilasters with pedestals frame the façade. The pedestals have inset panels, which are also present beneath the two windows. The porch was restored in 2005, referencing an old photograph of the house. The front door, protected by an exterior screen door, has a large glass panel. A sidelight is located on the right side of the front door.

S.Main155v2T.Wagner2013PRThe lawn features a decorative iron fence installed in 1970. Originally purchased from England, the fence was salvaged from Gilboy's Bookstore, Chestnut Street, Rochester, NY. Also, the iron grates on the basement windows were acquired at the same time.

Feature of the Neighborhood

With a large lot on the corner of South Main and Orchard Street, this Italianate style house with cupola and columned front porch is a landmark in the community. The decorative iron fence, setback house, and generous side yard fronting the corner represent a recognizable landscape within the village.

For more information on the FHPC and designated landmarks, go to the village preservation page or the village website.



SouthMain155 1976 A509-2PR
This photo was taken in 1976 as part of the Landmark Society survey of the village.

Fluted Doric columns grace the front porch with pedestals with inset panels.

Charles Steffen owned and operated Hupp Drug Company on South Main Street, circa 1932 - 1933.

The lawn features a decorative iron fence installed in 1970. Originally purchased from England, the fence was salvaged from Gilboy's Bookstore.

The front door, protected by an exterior screen door, has a large glass panel. A sidelight is located on the right side of the front door.

bottom5© Copyright 2004-2013

ARCHIVED August 2023. Please visit for current information.